American Issues Connector: Church and State

Children stand in a circle around a flagpole with the US flag, with their arms linked.

Students pray around a flagpole outside their school.

TRACK THE ISSUE

What is the proper relationship between government and religion?

The First Amendment says that government may not establish religion or interfere with the free exercise of religion. This is often referred to as “separation of church and state.” But Americans differ over how these clauses interact to prevent government from establishing religion while protecting the religious liberties of individuals. Use the timeline below to explore this enduring issue.

  • 1791 Bill of Rights

    First Amendment bars government involvement in religion.

  • 1840s Sabbatarian Controversy

    Congress debates whether to ban commerce and mail delivery on Sundays.

  • 1947 Everson v. Board of Education

    Supreme Court affirms separation of government and religion.

  • 1984 Federal Equal Access Act

    Law allows students to form religious clubs at public high schools.

  • 2000 Mitchell v. Helms

    Ruling allows private schools to receive federal funds for educational materials.

A painting of an early-1800s church, and church-goers walking in.

A church of the early 1800s

DEBATE THE ISSUE

Should prayer be allowed in public schools? One controversial topic in the church-state debate is the issue of prayer in public schools. Current law prohibits public school-sponsored prayers. Some Christians believe this ban violates their right to practice their beliefs.

“We’re deeply religious…. And we believe that prayer in school is a necessity because, although yes, my children say blessings at home and pray at home and they learn to do that at church, most of their waking hours are spent in school. So why shouldn’t they be able to pray, on the intercom, anywhere.”

—Pat Mounce, high school parent, Pontotoc, Mississippi

“I’m a Catholic and I hope a devout one, but I think that the public school classroom is no place for me to try and impose my world formula for prayer on children who don’t share it, and for that very reason, I don’t want my children in a public school classroom to be exposed to someone else’s religion or formula.”

—Senator Phillip A. Hart, Michigan

TRANSFER Activities

  1. Compare What views do Mounce and Hart share? On what point do they differ?
  2. Analyze How do you think each of these two speakers would have reacted to the issue of outlawing commerce on Sunday?
  3. Transfer Use the following Web site to see a video, try a WebQuest, and write in your journal. Web Code: neh-6802

End ofPage 268

Table of Contents

Prentice Hall: United States History CHAPTER 1 Many Cultures Meet (Prehistory–1550) CHAPTER 2 Europeans Establish Colonies (1492–1752) CHAPTER 3 The American Colonies Take Shape (1607–1765) CHAPTER 4 The American Revolution (1765–1783) CHAPTER 5 Creating the Constitution (1781–1789) CHAPTER 6 The New Republic (1789–1816) CHAPTER 7 Nationalism and Sectionalism (1812–1855) CHAPTER 8 Religion and Reform (1812–1860) CHAPTER 9 Manifest Destiny (1800–1850) CHAPTER 10 The Union in Crisis (1846–1861) CHAPTER 11 The Civil War (1861–1865) CHAPTER 12 The Reconstruction Era (1865–1877) CHAPTER 13 The Triumph of Industry (1865–1914) CHAPTER 14 Immigration and Urbanization (1865–1914) CHAPTER 15 The South and West Transformed (1865–1900) CHAPTER 16 Issues of the Gilded Age (1877–1900) CHAPTER 17 The Progressive Era (1890–1920) CHAPTER 18 An Emerging World Power (1890–1917) CHAPTER 19 World War I and Beyond (1914–1920) CHAPTER 20 The Twenties (1919–1929) CHAPTER 21 The Great Depression (1928–1932) CHAPTER 22 The New Deal (1932–1941) CHAPTER 23 The Coming of War (1931–1942) CHAPTER 24 World War II (1941–1945) CHAPTER 25 The Cold War (1945–1960) CHAPTER 26 Postwar Confidence and Anxiety (1945–1960) CHAPTER 27 The Civil Rights Movement (1945–1975) CHAPTER 28 The Kennedy and Johnson Years (1960–1968) CHAPTER 29 The Vietnam War Era (1954–1975) CHAPTER 30 An Era of Protest and Change (1960–1980) CHAPTER 31 A Crisis in Confidence (1968–1980) CHAPTER 32 The Conservative Resurgence (1980–1993) CHAPTER 33 Into a New Century (1992–Today) Reflections: Enduring Issues Five Themes of Geography Profile of the Fifty States Atlas Presidents of the United States Economics Handbook Landmark Decisions of the Supreme Court Documents of Our Nation English and Spanish Glossary Index Acknowledgments