Making a Model of a Periodic Table
Materials
plastic bag containing color chips
Procedure
Remove the color chips from the bag and place them on a flat surface, color side up.
Identify a property that you can use to divide the chips into groups. Then, identify a second property that you can use to order the chips from top to bottom within a group.
Use the properties you chose to arrange the chips into a table with rows and columns. Your teacher deliberately left out a chip fromeach bag. Decide where to leave a gap in your table for the missing chip.
Analyze and Conclude
Classifying What property did you use to divide the color chips into groups? What property did you use to arrange the chips within a group from top to bottom?
Making Generalizations What pattern repeats across each row of your table?
Predicting Based on its location on your table, describe the missing chip.
Comparing and Contrasting Compare the process you used to construct your table to the process Mendeleev used to make his table. Describe similarities and differences.
Mendeleev could not make a complete table of the elements because many elements had not yet been discovered. He had to leave spaces in his table for those elements. For example, Mendeleev placed bromine (Br) in Group VII because bromine and chlorine (Cl) have similar properties. This placement left four spaces in row 4 between zinc (Zn) and bromine. Mendeleev had only two elements, arsenic and selenium, to fill those spaces, based on their masses. He placed arsenic and selenium in the columns where they fit best and left gaps in the columns labeled Groups III and IV.
Mendeleev was not the first to arrange elements in a periodic table. He was not even the first to leave spaces in a periodic table for missing elements. But he was able to offer the best explanation for how the properties of an element were related to its location in his table.
An excellent test for the correctness of a scientific model, such as Mendeleev's table, is whether the model can be used to make accurate predictions. Mendeleev was confident that the gaps in his table would be filled by new elements. He used the properties of elements located near the blank spaces in his table to predict properties for undiscovered elements. Some scientists didn't accept these predictions. Others used the predictions to help in their search for undiscovered elements.
Why did Mendeleev place bromine in Group VII of his periodic table?